New Jersey’s Best Pies: The Results

Published On November 23, 2010 | By Deborah Smith, Executive Editor | Desserts, Jersey's Best

“Good apple pies are a considerable part of our domestic happiness.”
Jane Austen

The Top 5 winners of our Best Pies in New Jersey contest are….

Homestead Farmer’s Market in Lambertville. Established 23 years ago, the Homestead Farmers Market is known not only for its great baked goods, but for its great selection of  locally grown produce as well.  They offer a handy Harvest Schedule page on their website.  This time of year, the folks at the Market tell me that, of course, Pumpkin pie is the most popular customer choice, but in the spring, it is the amazing sounding Peachberry Pie; Peaches, Cherries and Blueberries, Oh My!

Delicious Orchards in Colts Neck. The orchard was established in 1911.  In 1959 after a successful summer of selling apples from a roadside stand, the 1200 square foot modern day Delicious Orchards was born. Over 2.5 million people visit Delicious Orchards each year.  The DO people tout their Apple Pie as being a top pick by customers.

The Macaroon Shop in Avon-by-the-Sea.  Here is another shop with quite a history.  Established in 1930 on the first floor of the North End Hotel in Ocean Grove, the bakery operated as a seasonal business during the summer months.  In 1981 they moved to their current location where they expanded their offerings to include cakes, cookies, danish, pies and desserts.   The Macaroon shop is known for its old-fashioned Coconut Custard and Pecan Pies. And, their Macaroons are still shipped anywhere in the United States like they have been since 1930.

Sun High Orchards in Randolph dates back to 1945 when Fred and Ranghild Bostrom planted the first fruit trees on Sun High’s 25 acres. Sun High offers pick your own apples and pumpkins, pony rides, even on-site birthday parties.  The owner, Joe Green, told Jersey Bites that their signature pies center around their home grown apples which include Regular Apple, Apple crumb, Apple Caramel Walnut, and Apple Raspberry pies. 

Johnson’s Corner Farm in Medford.  We’re not the first to notice Johnson’s Pies evidently. South Jersey Magazine beat us to it when they awarded Johnson’s Corner Farm with their “Best Apple Pie” award.  Pretty impressive for a bakery that only opened its 1600 square foot, professional doors in 2007.  In addition to their fresh baked goods, the farm offers a ton of activities for the kids including an upcoming visit with Santa on November 26th.

Congratulations to the winners and nominees !!

Vacchiano farms in Washington

Mendokers’ Bakery in Jamesburg

The Pie Store in Montclair

Mr. McGregor’s Garden in Jobstown

Marra’s Cafe and Bakery in Denville

Ye Olde Pie Shoppe in Little Silver

The General Store in Oldwick

Battleview Orchards in Freehold

DelPontes Lemon Meringue Pie (pictured in collage)

Four Seasons Diner, Eatontown

Every month, Jersey Bites will be polling our readers and Facebook/Twitter friends to get the inside scoop on the best bites in New Jersey.  Coming in December: Jersey’s Best Fruitcake. Yes, we said it, Fruitcake!!! just in time for Christmas.  I have a feeling this is going to get ugly. Come on, there has to be some places making yummy fruitcake and we’re counting on you to help us find them.  We’ll be calling for nominations after December 1st.

Let us leave you with a famous quote from one of our idols.

“Vegetables are a must on a diet. I suggest carrot cake, zucchini bread, and pumpkin pie.” Jim Davis, ‘Garfield’

Happy Thanksgiving

Like this Article? Share it!

7 Responses to New Jersey’s Best Pies: The Results

  1. karen jensen says:

    I think that Vacchioano Farms Apple Pie is better than DO. Have had pies from DO many, many times, but.. VF pie crust is much more tender and flaky.

  2. Movistar26 says:

    Ooooh, you can’t forget Emery’s in New Egypt!

  3. Cindy Allen says:

    So happy for the Macaroon Shop! They have the BEST pies!

  4. Velame says:

    Ye Olde Pie Shoppe puts out the best Chocolate Mousse pie. You have to try it! Happy Thanksgiving.

  5. Jersey Bites, thank you thank you thank you for having us in your contest, and we sure do thank your readers who voted for us! Winning was a great way to start the holiday season. You are appreciated!

  6. CJ says:

    The DelPontes Lemon Meringue Pie is that from Del Pontes in Bradley Beach, NJ?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>